Restorative Justice and Criminal Justice : Competing or Reconcilable Paradigms.
Hirsch, Andreas von.
Restorative Justice and Criminal Justice : Competing or Reconcilable Paradigms. - 1st ed. - 1 online resource (360 pages) - Studies in Penal Theory and Penal Ethics Series . - Studies in Penal Theory and Penal Ethics Series .
Half Title Page -- Title Page -- Title verso -- Preface -- Contents -- Notes on Contributors -- 1. Principles of Restorative Justice -- I. INSTITUTIONALISING CONSENSUS ON LIMITS -- II. DEMOCRATIC PRAGMATISM -- III. THINKING THEORETICALLY ABOUT RESTORATIVE JUSTICE -- IV. VALUES -- V. BOTTOM-UP VALUE CLARIFICATION -- VI. TRANSCENDING NORTH ATLANTIC JURISPRUDENCE -- VII. CONCLUSION -- REFERENCES -- 2. Specifying Aims and Limits for Restoratvie Justice: A 'Making Amends' Model? -- I. INTRODUCTION -- II. THE CRITIQUE OF RESTORATIVE JUSTICE -- III. A POSSIBLE RJ MODEL: 'MAKING AMENDS' -- IV. THE 'MAKING AMENDS' MODEL: SOME QUERIES -- V. 'MAKING AMENDS' AS A REPLACEMENT FOR CRIMINAL JUSTICE? -- VI. 'MAKING AMENDS' WITHIN A PROPORTIONALIST SENTENCING SYSTEM? -- VII. CONCLUSIONS -- REFERENCES -- 3. Restoration and Retribution -- I. SEEKING RECONCILIATION -- II. 'RESTORATION' AND 'RETRIBUTION' -- III. MEDIATION: CIVIL VERSUS CRIMINAL -- IV. CRIMINAL MEDIATION AND PUNISHMENT -- V. RESTORATIVE PUNISHMENT AND THE COURTS -- REFERENCES -- 4. Imposing Restoration -- I. INTRODUCTION: COERCION IN RESTORATIVE JUSTICE -- II. CONCLUSION -- 5. Some Sociological Reflections on Restorative Justice -- I. REVISITING A CLASSIC ARTICLE -- II. 'CIVILISATION' AND THE 'WISDOM OF PRE-MODERN SOCIETIES' -- III. APOLOGY AND THE SOCIAL MECHANISMS OF 'RESTORATION' -- IV. RESTORATIVE JUSTICE IN CONTEMPORARY SOCIETIES -- V. CONCLUSION -- 6. Restoration and Retribution in International Criminal Justice: An Explanatory Analysis -- I. RESTORATIVE JUSTICE INTERNATIONAL -- II. INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL JURISPRUDENCE -- III. INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL JUSTICE -- IV. JUSTICE AFTER GENOCIDE -- V. RESTORATION AND RETRIBUTION IN RECONCILIATION -- VI. FOR INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL JUSTICE -- REFERENCES. 7. Towards a Systemic Model of Restorative Justice: Reflections on the Concept, its Context and the Need for Clear Constraints -- I. INTRODUCTION -- II. CONCEPTUAL CONSTRAINTS: PROCESS VS. OUTCOME DEFINITIONS -- III. NORMATIVE CONSTRAINTS: PRINCIPLES OF PENALITY -- V. CONCLUSIONS -- REFERENCES -- 8. Proposed Basic Principles on the Use of Restorative Justice: Recognising the Aims and Limits of Restorative Justice -- I. BACKGROUND TO THE PROPOSED BASIC PRINCIPLES -- II. THE WORKING PARTY PREPARES BASIC PRINCIPLES -- III. COMMENT ON THE WORKING PARTY'S BASIC PRINCIPLES ON THE USE OF RESTORATIVE JUSTICE PROGRAMMES IN CRIMINAL MATTERS -- IV. CONCLUSION -- REFERENCES -- 9. Victims and Offenders -- I. INTRODUCTION -- II. ELEMENTS OF JUSTICE: (1) SEEING 'THE OTHER' AS A REAL PERSON -- III. ELEMENTS OF JUSTICE: (2) CONFLICTING PERSPECTIVES AND AGREED OUTCOMES -- IV. REDUCING CRIME -- V. CONCLUSION -- REFERENCES -- 10. Restorative Justice and Criminal Justice: Just Responses to Crime? -- I. BOUNDING RESTORATIVE JUSTICE -- II. HOW DIFFERENT IS RESTORATIVE JUSTICE FROM CRIMINAL JUSTICE? -- III. MAINSTREAM, PARALLEL OR BIT PLAYER? THE CHOICES FACING RESTORATIVE JUSTICE -- IV. JUSTICE CONSTRAINS, BUT JUSTICE LEGITIMATES -- REFERENCES -- 11. Mind the Gap: Restorative Justice in Theory and Practice -- I. INTRODUCTION -- II. RESTORATIVE JUSTICE AND CONFERENCING IN THEORY -- III. RESTORATIVE JUSTICE AND CONFERENCING IN PRACTICE -- IV. DISCUSSION -- V. A BRIEF CLOSING -- REFERENCES -- 12. Restorative Justice in Canada: From Sentencing Circles to Sentencing Principles -- OUTLINE OF CHAPTER -- I. EXAMPLES OF RESTORATIVE JUSTICE PROGRAMMING -- II. THE EVOLUTION OF RESTORATIVE JUSTICE CONSIDERATIONS IN SENTENCING -- III. JUDICIAL INTERPRETATION OF THE RESTORATIVE SENTENCING PROVISIONS -- IV. RECONCILING RESTORATIVE AND RETRIBUTIVE JUSTICE -- REFERENCES. 13. Restorative Justice in New Zealand -- I. INTRODUCTION -- REFERENCES -- 14. New, Improved Police-Led Restorative Justice? Action-Research and the Thames Valley Police Initiative -- I. INTRODUCTION -- II. THE THAMES VALLEY POLICE INITIATIVE IN RESTORATIVE CAUTIONING -- II. THE ACTION-RESEARCH PROJECT -- III. IMPROVING THE QUALITY OF RESTORATIVE JUSTICE -- IV. CONCLUSION -- REFERENCES -- 15. Evaluating Restorative Justice Practices -- I. WHAT WE KNOW NOW -- II. DIRECTIONS FOR FURTURE RESEARCH -- III. COMMUNITY-LEVEL OUTCOMES -- IV. CONCLUSION -- REFERENCES -- 16. Models, Challenges and The Promise of Restorative Conferencing Strategies -- I. INTRODUCTION -- II. TYPES OF RESTORATIVE PROGRAMMES -- II. OBSTACLES TO EFFECTIVE RESTORATIVE CONFERENCING -- III. CONCLUSION: THE PROMISE OF RESTORATIVE CONFERENCING -- REFERENCES -- Index.
This volume provides an analytic exploration of Restorative Justice and its potential advantages and disadvantages.
9781847311290
Restorative justice -- Congresses.
Criminal justice, Administration of -- Congresses.
Electronic books.
HV8688.R492 2003
344.03288
Restorative Justice and Criminal Justice : Competing or Reconcilable Paradigms. - 1st ed. - 1 online resource (360 pages) - Studies in Penal Theory and Penal Ethics Series . - Studies in Penal Theory and Penal Ethics Series .
Half Title Page -- Title Page -- Title verso -- Preface -- Contents -- Notes on Contributors -- 1. Principles of Restorative Justice -- I. INSTITUTIONALISING CONSENSUS ON LIMITS -- II. DEMOCRATIC PRAGMATISM -- III. THINKING THEORETICALLY ABOUT RESTORATIVE JUSTICE -- IV. VALUES -- V. BOTTOM-UP VALUE CLARIFICATION -- VI. TRANSCENDING NORTH ATLANTIC JURISPRUDENCE -- VII. CONCLUSION -- REFERENCES -- 2. Specifying Aims and Limits for Restoratvie Justice: A 'Making Amends' Model? -- I. INTRODUCTION -- II. THE CRITIQUE OF RESTORATIVE JUSTICE -- III. A POSSIBLE RJ MODEL: 'MAKING AMENDS' -- IV. THE 'MAKING AMENDS' MODEL: SOME QUERIES -- V. 'MAKING AMENDS' AS A REPLACEMENT FOR CRIMINAL JUSTICE? -- VI. 'MAKING AMENDS' WITHIN A PROPORTIONALIST SENTENCING SYSTEM? -- VII. CONCLUSIONS -- REFERENCES -- 3. Restoration and Retribution -- I. SEEKING RECONCILIATION -- II. 'RESTORATION' AND 'RETRIBUTION' -- III. MEDIATION: CIVIL VERSUS CRIMINAL -- IV. CRIMINAL MEDIATION AND PUNISHMENT -- V. RESTORATIVE PUNISHMENT AND THE COURTS -- REFERENCES -- 4. Imposing Restoration -- I. INTRODUCTION: COERCION IN RESTORATIVE JUSTICE -- II. CONCLUSION -- 5. Some Sociological Reflections on Restorative Justice -- I. REVISITING A CLASSIC ARTICLE -- II. 'CIVILISATION' AND THE 'WISDOM OF PRE-MODERN SOCIETIES' -- III. APOLOGY AND THE SOCIAL MECHANISMS OF 'RESTORATION' -- IV. RESTORATIVE JUSTICE IN CONTEMPORARY SOCIETIES -- V. CONCLUSION -- 6. Restoration and Retribution in International Criminal Justice: An Explanatory Analysis -- I. RESTORATIVE JUSTICE INTERNATIONAL -- II. INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL JURISPRUDENCE -- III. INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL JUSTICE -- IV. JUSTICE AFTER GENOCIDE -- V. RESTORATION AND RETRIBUTION IN RECONCILIATION -- VI. FOR INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL JUSTICE -- REFERENCES. 7. Towards a Systemic Model of Restorative Justice: Reflections on the Concept, its Context and the Need for Clear Constraints -- I. INTRODUCTION -- II. CONCEPTUAL CONSTRAINTS: PROCESS VS. OUTCOME DEFINITIONS -- III. NORMATIVE CONSTRAINTS: PRINCIPLES OF PENALITY -- V. CONCLUSIONS -- REFERENCES -- 8. Proposed Basic Principles on the Use of Restorative Justice: Recognising the Aims and Limits of Restorative Justice -- I. BACKGROUND TO THE PROPOSED BASIC PRINCIPLES -- II. THE WORKING PARTY PREPARES BASIC PRINCIPLES -- III. COMMENT ON THE WORKING PARTY'S BASIC PRINCIPLES ON THE USE OF RESTORATIVE JUSTICE PROGRAMMES IN CRIMINAL MATTERS -- IV. CONCLUSION -- REFERENCES -- 9. Victims and Offenders -- I. INTRODUCTION -- II. ELEMENTS OF JUSTICE: (1) SEEING 'THE OTHER' AS A REAL PERSON -- III. ELEMENTS OF JUSTICE: (2) CONFLICTING PERSPECTIVES AND AGREED OUTCOMES -- IV. REDUCING CRIME -- V. CONCLUSION -- REFERENCES -- 10. Restorative Justice and Criminal Justice: Just Responses to Crime? -- I. BOUNDING RESTORATIVE JUSTICE -- II. HOW DIFFERENT IS RESTORATIVE JUSTICE FROM CRIMINAL JUSTICE? -- III. MAINSTREAM, PARALLEL OR BIT PLAYER? THE CHOICES FACING RESTORATIVE JUSTICE -- IV. JUSTICE CONSTRAINS, BUT JUSTICE LEGITIMATES -- REFERENCES -- 11. Mind the Gap: Restorative Justice in Theory and Practice -- I. INTRODUCTION -- II. RESTORATIVE JUSTICE AND CONFERENCING IN THEORY -- III. RESTORATIVE JUSTICE AND CONFERENCING IN PRACTICE -- IV. DISCUSSION -- V. A BRIEF CLOSING -- REFERENCES -- 12. Restorative Justice in Canada: From Sentencing Circles to Sentencing Principles -- OUTLINE OF CHAPTER -- I. EXAMPLES OF RESTORATIVE JUSTICE PROGRAMMING -- II. THE EVOLUTION OF RESTORATIVE JUSTICE CONSIDERATIONS IN SENTENCING -- III. JUDICIAL INTERPRETATION OF THE RESTORATIVE SENTENCING PROVISIONS -- IV. RECONCILING RESTORATIVE AND RETRIBUTIVE JUSTICE -- REFERENCES. 13. Restorative Justice in New Zealand -- I. INTRODUCTION -- REFERENCES -- 14. New, Improved Police-Led Restorative Justice? Action-Research and the Thames Valley Police Initiative -- I. INTRODUCTION -- II. THE THAMES VALLEY POLICE INITIATIVE IN RESTORATIVE CAUTIONING -- II. THE ACTION-RESEARCH PROJECT -- III. IMPROVING THE QUALITY OF RESTORATIVE JUSTICE -- IV. CONCLUSION -- REFERENCES -- 15. Evaluating Restorative Justice Practices -- I. WHAT WE KNOW NOW -- II. DIRECTIONS FOR FURTURE RESEARCH -- III. COMMUNITY-LEVEL OUTCOMES -- IV. CONCLUSION -- REFERENCES -- 16. Models, Challenges and The Promise of Restorative Conferencing Strategies -- I. INTRODUCTION -- II. TYPES OF RESTORATIVE PROGRAMMES -- II. OBSTACLES TO EFFECTIVE RESTORATIVE CONFERENCING -- III. CONCLUSION: THE PROMISE OF RESTORATIVE CONFERENCING -- REFERENCES -- Index.
This volume provides an analytic exploration of Restorative Justice and its potential advantages and disadvantages.
9781847311290
Restorative justice -- Congresses.
Criminal justice, Administration of -- Congresses.
Electronic books.
HV8688.R492 2003
344.03288